Skip to content
DIRECT STAYSOLUTIONS
← The Direct Stay Journal

How to Build a Vacation Rental Email List Guests Choose to Join

By Direct Stay Solutions ·

The Direct Stay Journal · Operations and policies

I’d put a separate signup on your own rental website and tell people what they’ll get. Start with something you can actually send, like occasional notes about open weekends and seasonal offers. Keep the signup optional, and record when and where each person chose to join.

If you already have a spreadsheet of reservation emails, leave it out of your email marketing tool while you check where each address came from. An email address you received to get a guest into the cabin belongs in the reservation workflow.

Keep Airbnb reservations out of the marketing import

Use Airbnb’s permitted communication channels to manage Airbnb stays. Its off-platform policy restricts asking for contact information and using guest contact information for marketing. A platform email alias or an address provided for a permitted stay-related purpose stays out of your newsletter import. Check the policy version that applies to the booking before adding any invitation to a marketplace message, check-in flow, or Wi-Fi page. Airbnb Off-Platform Policy

For direct reservations, keep receipts, arrival instructions, and booking changes in the reservation workflow. Give visitors a separate choice to subscribe through your own site. If you offer a checkbox at direct checkout, leave it unchecked and let guests finish booking either way.

Write the signup in the same words you’d use with a guest

Fictional example. Cedar Bend Cabin wants to let people know when spring weekends open. I’d put this beside an email field on the cabin page and on a relevant trip guide.

Get occasional emails from Cedar Bend Cabin about open dates and seasonal offers. Unsubscribe anytime.

Label the button Send me cabin updates and link to your privacy notice. If your email tool supports confirmation by email, turn it on and test it. The address should be ready for campaigns after the person confirms. Keep that confirmation email focused on completing the signup.

Check what each address is eligible to receive

In your email tool, open the contact record. Look for where the address came from, the signup date, the version of the form or wording shown, and whether the person has since unsubscribed. If you change providers, carry over the suppression list, which tells the new tool who has opted out.

Say Cedar Bend has 34 addresses in an old export. All numbers are illustrative.

What Cedar Bend can verifyAddressesWhat I’d do
Own-site signup on record, still subscribed12Include in the first campaign after checking the suppression list.
Collected for a reservation only18Keep in the reservation system for appropriate stay messages.
Source or permission unclear4Leave out of the campaign.

I’d send to the 12 documented subscribers. Before that, I’d sign up with my own test address, confirm the subscription, and unsubscribe from a sample campaign. Then I’d try importing that test address again to see whether it stays suppressed. I’d also check that a necessary booking confirmation still reaches a test guest who opts out of marketing.

Run the U.S. commercial email checks before sending

The FTC looks at the primary purpose of a message when distinguishing commercial email from transactional or relationship email. I’d send the spring offer as its own campaign. Use accurate sender information, a subject line that matches the offer, clear identification as an ad where required, a valid physical postal address, and an easy unsubscribe link. Honor opt-outs within 10 business days. Check the rules for your audience and your email provider if you send outside the United States. FTC CAN-SPAM compliance guide

For Cedar Bend’s first campaign, I’d link to the cabin page with spring dates. If subscribers click but never get to availability, I’d open the same link on my phone and check where Check dates sits. With tracking set up, GA4 can show visits and date-button activity. The booking system is where I’d verify reservations. With a list of 12, I’d fix an obvious problem in the booking path before drawing conclusions from the numbers. Vacation rental email marketing campaign ideas

How Direct Stay would set up the signup

As part of a Managed Website project, we can scope a separate signup on your property page or trip guide and connect it to a compatible email tool. I’d test what the visitor sees when they subscribe and where the first email sends them. If it promises spring availability, the link should land where they can see the cabin and check those dates. Managed Website plan

Meet Dane, founder of Direct Stay Solutions

Dane Richardson, founder of Direct Stay Solutions

I came to this work through property management and eight years of operating Airbnb rentals. Send me the page where you’d invite people to sign up and one thing you’d like to tell them about. I’ll look at what the form promises and whether the first email takes them somewhere they can use it.