Skip to content
DIRECT STAYSOLUTIONS
← The Direct Stay Journal

How to Get Repeat Vacation Rental Guests

By Direct Stay Solutions ·

The Direct Stay Journal · Economics and distribution

A guest is more likely to return if they remember the rental by name, have a reason to take the trip again, and can find the same place when they’re ready. Start with the guests who already talk about coming back. Give them an easy way to find the cabin again and a good reason to pick their dates.

Give guests a reason to plan another stay

Pull a few recent reservations and read what guests mentioned in messages or reviews. Look for a trip that naturally repeats and a feature they’d miss if they stayed somewhere else. A family reunion may come back for the same weekend and the table that seats everyone. Two anglers may go back when the weather suits their usual trip. A couple who liked the screened porch might try a quieter weekday stay.

Fix anything that would make the second stay harder. If a guest had trouble finding the final turn, add a daylight photo and correct the arrival guide. If the same family brings two cars every year, make both parking spaces easy to identify. Keep the things guests liked consistent and explain anything important that has changed since their first visit.

Build a name guests remember and make dates easy to find

Pick a rental name guests can remember and spell, and use it consistently. If guests call it Cedar Bend Cabin, put that name on your domain or property page, confirmation, and welcome materials where your booking channel permits it. Try saying the name once to a friend. Ask them to find the cabin later by typing the name and town. If they land on a different rental or a general page without an obvious way to find yours, fix that path first.

On your own site, give each rental a permanent page. Show a photo a returning guest will recognize, put Check Cedar Bend dates near the top, and open availability for that exact cabin. On a phone, check that they can get from the link to the correct property, full total, and current terms without having to look it up again.

Want to see how this could work for your rental? Send me your listing and I’ll show you how I’d give past guests an easy way to find it and check dates again. Get your free 3-day website preview.

Send one useful invitation at the right time

Use the lead time from your own calendar. If reunion guests usually reserve four months before their trip, contact eligible subscribers shortly after those dates open. If couples plan quiet weekdays a few weeks out, invite them closer to the dates you can actually offer. Send one message with one link. Before you send, test it on a phone and check that the dates and quoted rules still make sense.

A repeat invitation for an opted-in direct guest

Subject. Next October is open at Cedar Bend Cabin

Hi Morgan, we just opened next October at Cedar Bend. If you’re planning another family weekend, you can check the same cabin you stayed in last fall. The screened porch and dining table are still there, and you’ll see the full price when you choose dates.

Link text. Check October dates at Cedar Bend Cabin.

Keep stay messages and marketing separate. Use a permission-based list for your direct channel and keep a record of how guests signed up. For marketplace bookings and guests, follow the channel’s contact and payment rules. Airbnb prohibits asking or encouraging guests to move current, future, or repeat bookings off its platform. Keep marketplace contact details out of your marketing list. Airbnb’s payment policy · Guest email and consent guide.

Offer a better direct price when the numbers work

A familiar place and first notice of next year’s dates may be enough. Try a lower direct rate when a permitted offer helps fill a period that usually sits empty. Pick the cabin, nights, and any minimum stay before sending it. Let guests see the complete quote so they can compare the same dates, fees, and terms.

Fictional example. A two-night stay brings in $600 before channel costs. With $300 in variable stay costs and a $120 marketplace charge, the stay leaves $180 before fixed costs. A $570 direct rate saves the guest $30 on that example rate. With the same $300 stay costs and a sample $17 processing fee, the owner keeps $253 before fixed costs. Factor in your website, booking software, acquisition, and other costs separately. If you would have booked the same nights direct at $600 anyway, the discount reduces what you keep. Work out your minimum direct rate.

Track who actually comes back

Track the first stay, property, month guests usually return, permitted contact status, and confirmed second stay. Use your reservation records to distinguish someone who clicked from someone who rebooked. Decide in advance whether you count the named guest or their household, and use the same rule when you compare seasons.

Start with a group you can follow for a full year. If 50 first-time guests checked out during last fall and eight booked another stay within 12 months of their first checkout, that’s a 16% repeat-booking rate for that group. Track direct and marketplace repeats separately. Record what you spent on offers, and compare prices, available dates, and email timing before you decide what to try again. See more campaign examples.

Give repeat guests a rental they can find by name and book again

At Direct Stay, I’ll build the site around the name and details guests remember, make the property page easy to find in search, and connect it to a compatible booking route for that rental. That gives guests who come to you directly a place to check dates, see the full price, and reserve. You can offer a lower direct rate when your costs leave room for it. See the booking tools we connect.

Send me your listing, the name guests call the place, and the trip they return for. I’ll show you how I’d make the path from remembering the rental to checking its dates easier.

Meet Dane, founder of Direct Stay Solutions

Dane Richardson, founder of Direct Stay Solutions

Tell me what a returning guest remembers about your rental. I’ll show how a branded site can help them find the same place, see what’s new, and check dates.

Get your free 3-day website preview